Current:Home > ContactProsecutors ask Massachusetts’ highest court to allow murder retrial for Karen Read-DB Wealth Institute B2 Reviews & Ratings
Prosecutors ask Massachusetts’ highest court to allow murder retrial for Karen Read
lotradecoin trading View Date:2024-12-26 04:01:05
BOSTON (AP) — Prosecutors have called on the state’s highest court to allow them to retry Karen Read for murder in the death of her Boston police officer boyfriend, arguing against defense claims that jurors had reached a verdict against some of her charges before the judge declared a mistrial.
Read is accused of ramming into John O’Keefe with her SUV and leaving him to die in a snowstorm in January 2022. Read’s attorneys argue she is being framed and that other law enforcement officers are responsible for O’Keefe’s death. A judge declared a mistrial in June after finding that jurors couldn’t reach agreement. A retrial on the same charges is set to begin in January.
In a brief filed late Wednesday to the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, prosecutors wrote that there’s no basis for dismissing the charges of second degree murder and leaving the scene of the accident.
There was “no viable alternative to a mistrial,” they argued in the brief, noting that the jury said three times that it was deadlocked before a mistrial was declared. Prosecutors said the “defendant was afforded a meaningful opportunity to be heard on any purported alternative.”
“The defendant was not acquitted of any charge because the jury did not return, announce, and affirm any open and public verdicts of acquittal,” they wrote. “That requirement is not a mere formalism, ministerial act, or empty technicality. It is a fundamental safeguard that ensures no juror’s position is mistaken, misrepresented, or coerced by other jurors.”
In the defense brief filed in September, Read’s lawyers said five of the 12 jurors came forward after her mistrial saying they were deadlocked only on a manslaughter count, and they had agreed unanimously — without telling the judge — that she wasn’t guilty on the other counts. They argued that it would be unconstitutional double jeopardy to try her again on the counts of murder and leaving the scene of an accident resulting in death.
Oral arguments will be heard from both sides on Nov. 6.
In August, the trial judge ruled that Read can be retried on all three counts. “Where there was no verdict announced in open court here, retrial of the defendant does not violate the principle of double jeopardy,” Judge Beverly Cannone wrote.
Read’s attorney, Martin Weinberg, argued that under Cannone’s reasoning, even if all 12 jurors were to swear in affidavits that they reached a final and unanimous decision to acquit, this wouldn’t be sufficient for a double jeopardy challenge. “Surely, that cannot be the law. Indeed, it must not be the law,” Weinberg wrote.
The American Civil Liberties Union supported the defense in an amicus brief. If the justices don’t dismiss the charges, the ACLU said the court should at least “prevent the potential for injustice by ordering the trial court to conduct an evidentiary hearing and determine whether the jury in her first trial agreed to acquit her on any count.”
“The trial court had a clear path to avoid an erroneous mistrial: simply ask the jurors to confirm whether a verdict had been reached on any count,” the ACLU wrote in its brief. “Asking those questions before declaring a mistrial is permitted — even encouraged — by Massachusetts rules. Such polling serves to ensure a jury’s views are accurately conveyed to the court, the parties, and the community — and that defendants’ related trial rights are secure.”
Prosecutors said Read, a former adjunct professor at Bentley College, and O’Keefe, a 16-year member of the Boston police, had been drinking heavily before she dropped him off at a party at the home of Brian Albert, a fellow Boston officer. They said she hit him with her SUV before driving away. An autopsy found O’Keefe had died of hypothermia and blunt force trauma.
The defense portrayed Read as the victim, saying O’Keefe was actually killed inside Albert’s home and then dragged outside. They argued that investigators focused on Read because she was a “convenient outsider” who saved them from having to consider law enforcement officers as suspects.
The lead investigator, State Trooper Michael Proctor, was relieved of duty after the trial revealed he’d sent vulgar texts to colleagues and family, calling Read a “whack job” and telling his sister he wished Read would “kill herself.” He said his emotions had gotten the better of him.
veryGood! (96)
Related
- US shoppers sharply boosted spending at retailers in July despite higher prices
- Taylor Swift Says She's Never Been Happier in Comments Made More Than a Month After Joe Alwyn Breakup
- Hostage freed after years in Africa recounts ordeal and frustrations with U.S. response
- Flash Deal: Save 69% On the Total Gym All-in-One Fitness System
- Ryan Reynolds on his 'complicated' relationship with his dad, how it's changed him
- Greening of Building Sector on Track to Deliver Trillions in Savings by 2030
- With 10 Appointees on the Ninth Circuit, Trump Seeks to Tame His Nemesis
- For the first time in 15 years, liberals win control of the Wisconsin Supreme Court
- Anchorage police shoot, kill teenage girl who had knife; 6th police shooting in 3 months
- 1 dead, at least 22 wounded in mass shooting at Juneteenth celebration in Illinois
Ranking
- Anchorage police shoot, kill teenage girl who had knife; 6th police shooting in 3 months
- Alaska Chokes on Wildfires as Heat Waves Dry Out the Arctic
- What does it take to be an armored truck guard?
- Building a better brain through music, dance and poetry
- Ryan Reynolds on his 'complicated' relationship with his dad, how it's changed him
- 10 Cooling Must-Haves You Need if It’s Too Hot for You To Fall Asleep
- Julian Sands' cause of death ruled 'undetermined' one month after remains were found
- Teens, trust and the ethics of ChatGPT: A bold wish list for WHO as it turns 75
Recommendation
-
What to stream: Post Malone goes country, Sydney Sweeney plays a nun and Madden 25 hits the field
-
A Young Farmer Confronts Climate Change—and a Pandemic
-
Soaring Costs Plague California Nuke Plant Shut Down By Leak
-
Global Warming Is Pushing Pacific Salmon to the Brink, Federal Scientists Warn
-
Red Cross blood inventory plummets 25% in July, impacted by heat and record low donations
-
A smart move on tax day: Sign up for health insurance using your state's tax forms
-
Aerie's Clearance Section Has 76% Off Deals on Swimwear, Leggings, Tops & More
-
'Oppenheimer' sex scene with Cillian Murphy sparks backlash in India: 'Attack on Hinduism'